LifestyleHome ImprovementNew York Friends Go Viral After Subway Trip With Stunning Thrift Store...

New York Friends Go Viral After Subway Trip With Stunning Thrift Store Find

Exclusive to Happily

A pair of friends loved a vintage mantel they found in a New York thrift store so much they decided to carry it home through the city on public transport.

Advertisement

Maddie Morris and Eve Matheson are more like sisters than best friends, having lived in the same Upper West Side building from birth before moving into the same building in the West Village as adults.

The besties, both 27, were in Chelsea to attend a show when they decided to kill some time waiting for a friend by visiting a thrift store across the street.

Two women smile while holding a vintage mantel upright inside a New York City subway car.
The best friends carry the mantel through the streets and rode the subway with their thrift find, navigating multiple stops with plenty of determination and humor.
Two young girls pose joyfully in front of a Christmas tree, dressed in festive outfits and smiling wide.
Maddie and Eve’s lifelong friendship began in childhood, growing up in the same building.

MORE THRIFTING NEWS: Thrifty Bride Refurbishes $25 Gown Into Dream Wedding Dress

There, Eve came across a stunning vintage mantel, which she and Maddie debated whether it would fit into either of their apartments.

Advertisement

Having not come to a solid conclusion, the friends decided to purchase the hand-carved mantel for $150 and figure out the rest later.

Eve and Maddie then carried the mantel out of the store before trying – and failing – to fit it into a yellow cab.

The duo were then forced to carry the mantel four avenues, three stops on the subway, and up six flights of stairs into Eve’s apartment.

Their friend Lexy was on-hand to help guide – and document – the friends’ navigation of New York.

Advertisement

Since getting the mantel home, Maddie and Eve rearranged Eve’s apartment to fit in the vintage piece.

Maddie joked that rearranging Eve’s apartment was the toughest part – along with her own acceptance that the mantel was more suited to Eve’s apartment than hers.

She added: “Barely anyone on the street or subway batted an eyelash: one of the many reasons to love New York.

“It looks so good in Eve’s living room.

A beautifully styled vintage green mantel sits in a cozy living room between two plaid armchairs, with a swan-patterned tapestry hanging above it.
After its urban journey, the ornate thrifted mantel found its forever home in Eve’s apartment, perfectly styled with books, photos, and a vintage swan tapestry.

MORE THRIFTING STORIES: $8 Thrift Store Painting Turns Out To Be Masterpiece Worth Thousands

Advertisement

“She let me style it because I love playing around with interior design – it has so much lived-in, well-loved charm, which matches her style perfectly.

“I had a feeling people would get a kick out of it when I posted it, but I had no idea it would get so big.

“It’s fun to be able to hear people’s own stories of great thrifting finds.

“A lot of people were quoting an episode of Friends in the comments, which neither of us has ever watched.

“People want to know where we found it… I have first dibs on the mantel if Eve ever moves, so no one get any ideas.”

Advertisement

Join our community of more than 500,000 Happily followers.

Advertisement

Editor's Picks

Advertisement

More good news

Embedded Style Sheet